Importer - Discus 4.0

[jacobi]

Misleading...

The poll states that "DCForum / Discus" is complete. I realized that these are two different forum softwares, contrary to what Jerry said here. I have posted on the Converter request thread for clarification as to the resolution to this situation.

[Jerry]

Do you mean there will be a importer which you can configure yourself to import a forum-database without a specific importer? I hope so, because I'm still not sure when to buy vbulletin, now and check if I can convert my db or wait a long time and hope there is someone in my neighboorhood that can help me.

Nope, you still have to write the importer, though most of the work is done in impex, just use the structure and map the fields, though it will take some programming knowledge to do that.

[Steve Machol]

For custom importers post a request over at vbulletin.org.

[sjaakie]

Are you running Discus Pro with a mysql backend ? I guess with those figures you must be ?

Currently there isn't an importer for Discus Pro, though with the release of the importer system next week. Due to its nature it makes writing new importers very quick so with demand for a Discus Pro importer it could be done quickly.

Do you mean there will be a importer which you can configure yourself to import a forum-database without a specific importer? I hope so, because I'm still not sure when to buy vbulletin, now and check if I can convert my db or wait a long time and hope there is someone in my neighboorhood that can help me.

[BlueFlame]

I am sure Jerry is working on them in order of Votes recieved

[chrisvonc]

LOL.. I would even consider that as well. I just want the messages. All my users have long since recreated their accounts but lots of good tech info still there that would be good to add to the new system.

[Snotek]

We would like to convert away from Discus so badly that we would consider paying you to get a converter written!

[Snotek]

To vote or not to vote?

Vote away : http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/showthread.php?t=100464

I can't vote. And I'm still looking for that Discus Pro 4.0 conversion. I noticed it's about 5-6 down the line in the poll... how quickly are you guys/gals getting the conversions made?

[jacobi]

My confusion
I was just trying to differentiate between the file and dB one, though it looks like either version can run with either back end ? I'll have to do some more home work, I've been a bit busy lately

Both the file-based and SQL-based use the same structure; and you can very easily (from within the forum's administration/control panel) "toggle" between the two. The SQL only helps parse the users and index. The messages/posts are still kept in a flat file format. Ergo, I think the flat file would be the default people would want; the SQL is simply an "enhancement." Therefore, for the sake of consistency and clarity, I would urge you to just have a "Discus" option in the vote.

Whenever you're ready -- and don't rush: I'm just relieved to hear this isn't completely falling off the radar -- PM me for an administrative password and FTP access to my Discus forum, if you'd like to poke around and experiment. I'll back everything up, and since it's in archive mode, there really isn't too much damage "experimenting" could do. Obviously, importation of user data is priority one, with messages next.

[Jerry]

My confusion

I'll have to reword the poll or add a new one DC+ Should be "Discus dB" (with the MySQL backend) and "Discus file" as the file based one, or something like that.

I was just trying to differentiate between the file and dB one, though it looks like either version can run with either back end ? I'll have to do some more home work, I've been a bit busy lately

[jacobi]

DC+ is Discuss Plus, do you mean the flat file system one ?

There's a Discus Pro, but no "plus." I started with them back in '99, and it's been simply known as "Discus" or "Discus Pro" for awhile (they decidedly don't have a cool acroynm like "vB." That might be why people here are confused.

One of the ways you can find a Discus board on the Net is by doing a search for "Discus." The program has traditionally (i.e., without hacking) required that the program be installed in a directory by that name. In other words, the name is inexorably tied to the program.

http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/image...ine=1081975376Thanks for the clarification, anyhow. I am excited about the possibilty of conversion. Any chance of changing the name in the poll without cancelling out votes?

P.S. - I'm using the MySQL-powered backend for the userbase.

[Jerry]

Um... am I missing something? There's nowhere to vote for Discus. Do we vote for "other?" Please tell me this won't fall through the cracks, into oblivion? If memory serves, there are at least five people I've found on this forum over the past year who've expressed an interest in Discus.

DC+ is Discuss Plus, do you mean the flat file system one ?

[jacobi]

Vote away : http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/showthread.php?t=100464

Um... am I missing something? There's nowhere to vote for Discus. Do we vote for "other?" Please tell me this won't fall through the cracks, into oblivion? If memory serves, there are at least five people I've found on this forum over the past year who've expressed an interest in Discus.

[Jerry]

Vote away : http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/showthread.php?t=100464

[jacobi]

Hello again, friends!

I'm still here and still interested in converting my archived Discus board, or at least the users. My host took away remote MySQL access, making using the spreadsheet-like client for managing importation of information much less convenient (I'm not a programmer).

As I mentioned in the thread that's linked to above, I was lead to believe by Scott that something was in the works, and then... nothing. I would surmise that he became much busier with development of vB3.

While Discus was an "ahead-of-its-time" product with robust features, its PERL nature has made it sometimes difficult to manage, almost impossible to hack, and much slower than a PHP/MySQL-based forum like vBulletin. In other words, I found "greener pastures" here, but it sure would be nice to bring my existing cows over to graze (I don't know if that was the best metaphor, but I'm from Wisconsin, USA -- the dairy state).

It looks like ataraxia might also be interested in such a converter script.

Many thanks again... and I am still amazed at what a stupendous upgrade 3.0 is from the previous version!