Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

We call for a proper search feature in vbulletin 4.x.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Mark.B
    replied
    Originally posted by Markowitch View Post
    We have now decided to wait for 4.1.5 and if the search is still not optimal - we will remove the entire vBulletin search segment
    You might as well do this right now. Search isn't going to change in 4.1.5.

    The greater likelihood is, it will not be until after vB5. Now that the editor is done, what you see with vB4 is pretty much what you're going to get, bar bugfixing and the CMS improvements which are a couple of releases away. vB4 *is* what you see now, rightly or wrongly.

    Leave a comment:


  • Andreas
    replied
    Originally posted by Markowitch View Post
    It is called the a Publishing Suite, so what it is worth, when we can not search the entire publishing content?
    You can search the entire content, you just will not get all results if your query is not specific enough, eg. yields too many results.

    For everything else, we will use google's custom search.
    .... which also limits the results to 1,000

    Leave a comment:


  • Markowitch
    replied
    Thanks for all replies
    Originally posted by wcguy View Post
    Sorry, I've stopped dropping by, see things haven't changed much.

    http://tracker.vbulletin.com/browse/...ream-issue-tab
    Exactly...

    Originally posted by Steve Machol View Post
    As I also said "The higher you make this, the more server resources you will use." This also means the more likely you will run into server timeouts or memory issues.
    We are located on the same server, with the same power, settings, options etc. as we were before the change to vBulletin Publishing Suite, so server capacity is no the problem for us.

    Let mi just round off with the following statement: users come and go, while the content of the Forum remain, and would like to be searchable as long as the forum exist. Anything less is simply not good enough.

    If the contents of the Forum shall not exceed the forum's search capability is vBulletin not useful for anything other than short-term purposes. It is called the a Publishing Suite, so what it is worth, when we can not search the entire publishing content?

    We have now decided to wait for 4.1.5 and if the search is still not optimal - we will remove the entire vBulletin search segment and replace it with our own search segment to search only for users' own threads and posts. For everything else, we will use google's custom search. If it appears that the search still not functioning in accordance to our needs, we will switch to another board system.

    We intend to exist for many years yet and we can not accept that the longer we exist, the more posts and threads disappear because the search does not include the entire contents of the forum.

    Have a nice day and thanks for all replies.
    Last edited by Markowitch; Fri 24th Jun '11, 11:22pm.

    Leave a comment:


  • Octavius
    replied
    Price difference!

    Leave a comment:


  • Alfa1
    replied
    Originally posted by Octavius View Post
    Hilarious.
    Do you mean the dysfunctionality of vbulletin sphinx compared to digitalpoint's version or the price difference between DP's sphinx and axivo? Or both?

    Leave a comment:


  • Octavius
    replied
    Hilarious.

    Leave a comment:


  • Alfa1
    replied
    Originally posted by Octavius View Post
    Wow that looks nice. I'd buy it for $25.

    Do you know of a better one?
    http://www.axivo.com/community/threa...ght-2-2-0.105/
    Cost: $1100 with branding. Branding free: $1600
    Quite a big leap from $25

    Leave a comment:


  • Octavius
    replied
    Originally posted by Alfa1 View Post
    Is that a joke?

    [ATTACH=CONFIG]53226[/ATTACH]
    Wow that looks nice. I'd buy it for $25.

    Do you know of a better one?

    Leave a comment:


  • Steve Machol
    replied
    As I also said "The higher you make this, the more server resources you will use." This also means the more likely you will run into server timeouts or memory issues.

    Our forums are set to 300. Anything higher would produce server issues for a forum our size.

    I do know that search is being worked on for 4.1.5. However I am not sure it will solve your 5000 search results issue. That would be an issue even with vB3.x.

    Nonetheless please feel free to make a 'New Feature' request here:

    http://tracker.vbulletin.com/secure/IssueNavigator.jspa

    We take all suggestions into account when determining the feature set for new versions but unfortunately we cannot confirm whether a particular feature will be included in a version.

    Leave a comment:


  • Markowitch
    replied
    Thanks for all replies
    Originally posted by Steve Machol View Post
    That is limited by this setting: Admin CP -> vBulletin Options -> Message Searching Options -> Maximum Search Results to Return Note: The higher you make this, the more server resources you will use. Also vB3 worked the same way.
    We have done exactly that before our question was posted. Without it solved the problem.

    We have set the Maximum Search Results to Return to 5000 and conducted a test. The result was that only under half of the posts "went back", with date on the oldest line corresponding to test-users' first post in the forum, and the latest date, corresponding to test-user's last posting in the forum. Test-users have posted about 4200 posts. Number of search results that appeared was about 1900 from the entire period the test-user has posted on the forum.

    This means that the search has "selected" among a arrivered posts, because total 2300 posts seems missing from the period covered by the search. Where are the rest of the posts and why are some of posts shown, while others do not?

    A forum without a reliable search within their own content is half useless. Not all queries can be performed by google custom search.

    Please note that this is a new problem that only emerged after we moved to the Publishing Suite, 4.1.4 now.

    Can we expect that improvement of this feature has a serious priority?

    Thanks in advance

    Leave a comment:


  • wcguy
    replied
    Sorry, I've stopped dropping by, see things haven't changed much.

    http://tracker.vbulletin.com/browse/...ream-issue-tab

    Leave a comment:


  • Alfa1
    replied
    Originally posted by Mark.B View Post
    vB have released an "unofficial" plugin on this site which works perfectly
    Is that a joke?

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Sphinx Search for vBulletin 4 2011-06-12 20-04-29.jpg
Views:	2
Size:	72.0 KB
ID:	3682493

    Leave a comment:


  • Mark.B
    replied
    You could install sphinx search, vB have released an "unofficial" plugin on this site which works perfectly, also the user "DigitalPoint" on this site sells a sphinx plug in too.

    Leave a comment:


  • Steve Machol
    replied
    That is limited by this setting:

    Admin CP -> vBulletin Options -> Message Searching Options -> Maximum Search Results to Return

    Note: The higher you make this, the more server resources you will use. Also vB3 worked the same way.

    Leave a comment:


  • We call for a proper search feature in vbulletin 4.x.

    Why not all results of the search will appear when users search all of their posts or threads? We have done everything by the book, but it seems that we can not view all results of the search, just a part of them. Users miss up to half of their posts and threads, where only half of the 4000 post show up in search results. Why? Where's the rest?

    Moreover, we have no possibility to jump directly to the last search page. Why has this feature been removed?

    We are not a chat. We deal with medical issues and we need a search that includes all posts and threads that are written on the forum at all times. We have just the right settings for the search feature in ACP. We have done everything correctly.

    If we do not have a proper search in the forums, we can not use vbulletin.

    We find the search feature in version 4.x is far too advanced and unnecessarily complicated. It contains too many unnecessary options, users perceive as too demanding a high degree of insight into how the search function is structured. As it works now on our board, vbulletin search function is too complicated and unreliable.

    We call for a proper search feature in vbulletin 4.x. .. as it was in versions 3.x. .. which we could adapt for our own needs. We can no longer do so.
    Server Type: Linux
    Web Server: cgi
    PHP: 5.2.14
    MySQL Version: 5.1.56-log

Related Topics

Collapse

  • pmquist
    Search results problem
    by pmquist
    We are trying to add a second search module on the right side of search page which will show the results from a particular Channel according to the search term.
    We have added the search module and...
    Tue 27th Mar '18, 8:39am
  • musicoff
    Search doesn't works!
    by musicoff
    Hi everyone.
    We're experiencing serious issues with Search: threads that exist and that we can see in the boards are not found using the search engine (both simple and advanced, searching titles...
    Wed 1st Feb '17, 6:00am
Working...
X